Dec 4 2009

A Philosophical Dilemma

AA PassengerThe picture shown here is of a passenger on an American Airlines flight, as taken by a concerned flight attendant. I have seen it passed around and discussed, usually in discussions of whether or not larger passengers ought to be charged for a second seat.

After seeing this picture initially, my reaction was along the lines of, “Well, he got himself this way so he should be responsible for it!” But now I’m in a bit of a philosophical crisis over it. Look closely at the photo – this man is not only much wider but also far taller than the other passengers. Should this passenger be of a “normal” BMI, it is likely that he may require more than one seat anyway! Somehow I feel that it is wrong to charge an “average”-weight-but-very-tall passenger extra for their ride, but right to charge an obese person more. Why? Why do I feel this way?

No matter the reason for a person to require special accommodations, the end result is the same. Why, then, do I feel that a fat person should be charged more? Am I seeking to punish the grave social sin of being fatter than is deemed acceptable? Of course, it can be pointed out that one is not likely to grow to such a size without consuming animal flesh (wish does indeed fill me with a sickening sort of dread), but 98% of Americans (and ~90% worldwide) do the same and I am certainly not in the business of seeking retribution against them.

Have I identified a prejudice against fat people in my own mind?


Apr 26 2009

Project: Reading the Whole Damn Bible – Joshua

The Book of Joshua isn’t particularly interesting, though much more heinously bloody than all previous. It recounts the string of genocidal conquests into Canaan which occurred between the death of Moses and the death of his second-in-command, Joshua. Of the people found there, God orders all of them put to death without exception. Of course, exceptions are made about which God is peculiarly silent.

It wasn't the first time Israel tooted its own horn.In chapter 2 two Isrealite spies are aided by Rahab, a treasonous resident of Jericho. Rahab is either a prostitute or an innkeeper, about which the NIV is unsure. (Seems like a fairly big difference, yes?) She aids the spies in exchange for her and her family’s lives. After a successful campaign (the one where the city is marched around for seven days and all the walls fall), she lives among Israel. This story confuses me. So God commands destruction of all the people of Canaan without exception, yet exceptions are allowed?

Chapter 7 shows the inconsistency of these edicts. A man named Achan looted a few items during the conquest of Jericho, all of which was to be destroyed. After suffering a minor loss in Ai and some others dying of sickness (revealed in 22:20-22), Joshua is told that it was because some among them secretly sinned. (Sure, all bad things that happen are punishment for sin. It can’t be that you weren’t adequately prepared. Noooo. Joshua also preemptively blames intermarriage for military failures in 23:12-13. What about everybody who will marry a relative of Rahab?) Upon interrogation Achan confesses and is punished with death for himself and his entirely family, again directly acting in opposition to Deuteronomy 26:16.

I was impressed with the Gibeonites, a group of Hivites, whom deceived Joshua in chapter 9. After they heard of the fates of Jericho and Ai, some men were dressed shabbily and sent to meet Israel in order to forge a treaty. They claimed to have come far away and proffered their shabby wares as proof. (Smooth!) They are believed, God is not consulted nor does he intercede, and a peace treaty (sworn by the God of Israel) is made. Shortly thereafter the ruse is discovered and all Gibeon LOLs at them. Just kidding, they become the Israelites’ slaves. Um… good going?

In the next chapter occurs the other memorable scene from the Book of Joshua: the Sun stands still. Of course, nobody – apparently even God – knew that the Sun was stationary (Well, not really, but I’m sure God didn’t know this either.) and that the Earth turns and revolves around it. And when, as logic would dictate, the Earth stood still (perhaps the genesis of this term) gravity was not noted to have suddenly decreased. Also no word was of how hot the Earth – especially in a desert place like Canaan – became that day. Surely even an ignorant such as the author of the Book of Joshua knew the relation between the Sun being “up” and the temperature rising.

In chapter 20, the rules for people acquitted of murder are changed or contradicted. In Numbers 35:24-26 the person in question must remain in the Levite city until the high priest dies, but Joshua 20:6 states that they may leave upon being cleared of the charge. Though I do not complain about laws becoming more just, it does bother me that they are not constant. If their god is perfect, ought not these laws remain the same for more than some fifty years? (It’s not as though their society or technology improved much during the interim.)

Chapter 22 relates the anecdote about the tribes East of the River Jordan erecting a replica of an altar in order to remind those there of their god. The Western tribes get upset thinking that they had resorted to idolatry (which is likely given that these people have a history of worshipping new gods just two weeks after the old becomes occupied with other work [Exodus 32:1]). This was very funny to me because isn’t that exactly what a graven image/idol is? Surely people even back then were not stupid enough to think that the little statue got up and did the bidding of worshipers while nobody was looking, right?

The whole book is about genocidal military conquest, misplaced blame, stupidity, long lists of non-Israelites murdered, and more long lists of land allotments (upon which other people still live). The pervading themes of Joshua are the bigotry and smallness of the Israelites and of their god. “Thou shalt not murder” (Exodus 20:13) and other commandments clearly only apply to Israelites (who have not incurred magical wrath) and those whom curry their favor. My reading thus far has only strengthened my conviction that even if magic and all that nonsense could be real, a god like this is not worthy of worship. Any just-minded person would certainly rather spend eternity in Hell than with a monster like Israel’s God.


Oct 21 2006

Nightmares Do Come True

If you’ve been reading my blog for more than, oh, a month, you would know a bit about the nightmares I have of the fat men devouring copious amounts of animal flesh. The villains’ faces had always remained piggish, yet vague and without identity. Today, their faces materialized right in front of me: they were those of people I care about.

Today was Sina’s thirtieth birthday. Somebody had chosen a restaurant called Espetus to dine at for the occasion. After checking out their site’s menu and finding nothing but a “meat selection,” I began to have my doubts as to whether I was truly welcome at the party. I tried to call the restaurant to see what, if any, vegan options they had. The phone was never answered. Roman asked Raquel whether they had anything for me, and she assured him that there was. I took a deep breath and tried to accustom myself to the idea of watching people feast upon the innocent for two solid hours. “It’s not my birthday,” I kept telling myself.

Roman and I reached the restaurant on time, but before anybody else. Wind annoying whipped my hair two and fro for half an hour before we were allowed inside. This was bearable, however much I wished to look nice today, but you must admit that it doesn’t contribute much to fostering a good mood!

We finally got in shortly after Junior and Erica arrived. Their presence, though they said little to me, helped my mood a bit. I have to admit that I like them both much, though I know them little. As we sat, the others slowly trickled into their seats. After the last people arrived, it was revealed, much to my horror, that the waiters would be bringing the meat on long, steel spikes, to the table and cutting up animals before my eyes. I felt sick.

The salad bar had less salad than dairy products and seafood. I eventually settled upon white rice, grilled eggplant, and tomatoes. One waiter in particular was very kind to me and personally pointed out everything that was fit for my consumption. He explained to me that he used to be a vegetarian, himself, but working where he did made him bend the other way. All I could say was, “It must be hard,” although I had wanted to say, “They beat the humanity out of you.”

I shoveled the rice down my throat as quickly as I could. I knew I had precious little time in which I could get food down before I’d be too sick to eat any more. Soon, the desfile del muerto arrived and I couldn’t bear to so much as look at the spectacle. I would periodically catch a glimpse of the defiling of the departed, and my stomach would turn. They all sat around laughing and joking, as though they were imprevious to the suffering of their supper.

It was too much to bear; my recurring hellish phantasm was playing out right before my eyes and all I could do was divert them. I was frozen, like in a dream before you realize that you are asleep. I sat there painfully twisting my cotton napkin around my hand until it turned purple. The pain in my arm did little to alleviate my conscience’s anguished cries. I tried telling myself, “It’s just that dream again. Nobody I care about is this cruel!” but I couldn’t make it stick. The faces were clear at last: the people in Roman’s family were the pig-men of my most chilling nightmares.

At last I came out of my head and ran to the restroom. The restaurant was of such a caliber where there were no stalls, as I had hoped: just one room for men and one for women. I had to stand in the hall for a while as waiters whisked the dead into the dining area and empty picks into the kitchen. Naomi stood beside me in line for a minute or two before I got in. I felt bad that I couldn’t talk to her – the tears had started to fall and I couldn’t stand to look anybody in that wretched place in the face. I got into the bathroom and heard a chain saw. I’ve seen enough and heard enough to know that they were sawing up an animal in the back. I cried uncontrollably. I looked at the monster in the mirror. I hate her. I don’t want to be her anymore, with the remnants of the dead she had eaten long ago still sickeningly disfiguring her body. I stuck my head into the toilet, fingers down the throat, let it go. I’ll be damned if I have to keep remnants of my old self around! I will never look back! I want my bones to stick out of my skin – the ultimate statement against the fat men devouring the innocent. That damn hospital got me eating again; I was stupid enough to think that my body may be fine as it is. Now I remember why I’m doing this: I have to reach my goal, gain control, set myself free of this world’s miserable confines. I will transcend it!

My mouth tasted like soap by the time I got back to the table. Soon, I had to hide my face behind my hair in order to mask the crying. I realize that they probably figured out that something was wrong, but thankfully nobody said anything. “Mila, what’s wrong?” What could I say? “You are!”? I pondered for a while the irony of the situation: Everybody else at the table was a Christian. Christians extoll the beauty of His creation and the sanctity of life, yet at this very moment they sit around a table devouring the sinless beings of His masterful creation. Maybe it’s suiting that they use the cross as their symbol? After all, it was the instrument of oppression, torture, and murder.

I began to twist the napkin again. One person whose name I forget but Ro says is Ruthie’s brother, kept eating and eating and eating. It took every ounce of control I possessed to ignore the scene. Damn you, conscience! Who ever heard of an Atheist so concerned with morality and justice? Why must I be cursed with such a strong sense of right and wrong? I guess this must be my cross to bear.

Naomi was kind enough to take Roman and I home. I felt bad that I still couldn’t look at either she or Ro, but that’s how it was. I hope her car seats weren’t real leather. After we got inside our apartment, I cried for a long time. Ro said that he would become Vegan, too. As much as I would like him to do so, I don’t want him to do it just so it’d make me feel better. He’d just go around eating animal products in secret and that wouldn’t be right. He says he’s honestly been thinking about it lately, but I have my doubts. I sat in the closet and listened to the videos about slaughterhouses that he was watching. After I came out, he seemed unhappy, but I cannot be sure if he was genuinely as upset about them as they had made me. I gave Ro some literature to read and urged him not to make a quick decision about the subject.

Why do morals have to be complex like this? Obviously, the moral decision would be to completely agree with him and induct him into a healthier, compassionate Vegan lifestyle, but some part of me cries out that he may not be happy with that. With all the obvious immorality of meat-eating, why am I apprehensive to rubber-stamp Ro’s sudden desire to go Veg? I know he’s been talking about cutting back his animal consumption lately, but I don’t want to force him into something good. The feeling is complex.

Do you remember being told as a child that despite wanting to be an adult, upon reaching adulthood, you’ll soon wish to return to your youth? I always thought that this sentiment had something to do with work, bills, taxes, and the like – I had no clue that it was about the moral obscurity that comes with it. As each day passes, I learn about one more thing to add to the collage that is life. Not one piece matches another. I asked my parents about this recently. They told me that they had indeed meant that the burden of adulthood was work, bills, taxes, et al. I guess I’m all alone in the quest for transcendence.


Oct 8 2006

A Little More Truth

I’ve been thinking more about my condition lately than I once did. I’m only a pound-and-a-half overweight now and my physical and emotional states are continuing to deteriorate. I’ve been dealing with some strange new feelings that I’ve only started to acknowledge, feelings that I don’t feel quite right expressing in their entirety at the moment. At this time, let it suffice to say that they are complex and painful.

Now, for something I’ve only told two of the three most wonderful people I know (Ro and Nilla) and think that I should say publicly because I need help. I have Bulimia Nervosa on top of the starvation eating disorder (I can’t say it’s Anorexia Nervosa because I’m not underweight) I usually only eat for appearances and I’m ruining my health. That isn’t all: I’ve been seriously contemplating suicide lately. I’ve gone over so many different methods in my head and they all sound better than living most of the time: jumping in front of BART, falling out the window, drinking myself to death (which is possible if I chug fast enough)… they all sound like a lovely closing.

I spent the weekend with Nilla – the aforementioned wonderful person, Kassandra, Dan, Ron, and to some extent Joe, Charlene and (the other) Dan. (They’re different than the sort of people I’m used to, but I like them very much!) I drank some Kahlua (my weapon of choice) on Friday night and said some things that, though I meant them, I wish I hadn’t said. I got to thinking. Nilla always makes me think – that’s one of the reasons why I love him. I always end up crying when he’s around because he’s reached something deep inside of me that nobody else was able to reach. I think it’s because he’s beautiful, though he denies it. But I digress. He made me think. He made me realize that I need to tell Ro some things about how I’m feeling and that I need help to deal with this! I really do need help and I don’t know where to start. I’ve always heard that admitting that you need help is the first step. Well, here I am… where do I go from here? I don’t know. I don’t want to stop losing weight yet, I’m so ugly. (Please don’t disagree with me on this point. I don’t want any damn compliments. Just ignore it if you don’t agree.) I don’t think the eating disorder is the source of the problem, but only a symptom of it.

I’m not at a point where I don’t feel like I’ll ever be happy again. If that were the case, I’d have jumped already. However, I’m at a point where I don’t feel like the future happiness that is in store for me is going to be rewarding enough to continue through this pain. I feel so hollow, I feel like I’m losing or am about to lose something I treasure more than life itself. I feel like I have no control over my life and I simply need to wrest myself from the outside forces that command me in order to restore order once again. I’ve mastered my impulses, but now my emotions are running amok. Where do I start?


Sep 10 2006

Wretched Monsters

Roman and I went to the Farmer’s Market at San Francisco’s UN Plaza today where we I bought a ton of mushrooms and some edamame. We were still searching for avocados when we came across a stall selling live quails, confined to stacked crates, 5-7 birds each. About four people were clamoring over the birds as Roman and I walked away. We didn’t get far before I started crying over the unfortunate birds. Just who do these people think they are? Confining frightened animals to cages only to destroy and devour them later. Quails don’t exist for this. No animal does. In my mind, I keep seeing those people from the stall picking up the birds and ripping out their fragile little throats with their teeth. Fucking monsters!

Ironically, Ro and I went to a Taco Bell today, which is also a KFC. I had a veganized value menu item as Ro devoured cow flesh smothered in beans. The pictures in this restaurant were especially disturbing. Each picture was of happy, healthy-looking children, prominently displaying a bucket of assorted chicken carnage. Imagine if you will, happy-looking young kids holding buckets of slaughtered infants with the same sappy smiles on their faces. That’s how I see it. Filthy little monsters: they’re so terrible that they don’t even realize what they’re doing.

In Korea, they hang dogs by the neck and beat them to death with baseball bats because they believe the adrenaline-filled meat makes men virile. Does this repulse you? It does me. This is just one among so many lies about the benefits of consuming animal products. You know, like the whole “drinking bovine mammary fluid makes kids healthy!” Bullshit. Cruel industries have so much to gain by your believing their lies.

I find myself becoming more adverse to obese people these days. This isn’t because of how they look, but how they got there. You can’t become that big without eating a lot of animal flesh. Think about it! You’d have to eat all day, every day to get that big on a plant-based diet. You’d probably even find yourself hard-pressed to get that large on a balanced omnivorous diet. I keep seeing these people in my mind shoving raw steaks into their gaping mouths, grease slathered all over their bodies, blood dripping from their teeth, eyes glazing over at the thought of consuming even more innocent animals. This may be why I hate myself even more these days. I know the scale says I’m dropping weight, but when I look in the mirror, I keep seeing the 222-pound poker that I was almost a year ago. I keep dreaming of myself devouring animals with the obese men in Rascal Scooters. Sometimes I wake up and cry. Why did it take me so long to realize what I was doing?! I must be a monster, too. I dry my tears on my size-10 pants… and it makes me feel a little better.

I’m still crying a bit over those quails. They were beautiful little birds, and all those wretched monsters at the market today cared about was how they’d taste in a cranberry dressing. I hate you! I fucking hate you!